Saving More: Budget-Friendly Cloth Diapering

Written by: Johanna Hatch, CD, CCE

© thefeministbreeder.com

My husband Evan and I welcomed our first child, Liam, in November of 2009, one of the first parenting decisions we made was to use cloth diapers. Evan and I are known among our friends and family as champion penny-pinchers, so our decision was no surprise to anyone. To diaper a baby from birth to potty training, it costs approximately $1500 to use disposable diapers, compared with about $300 for prefold diapers and covers (and for more comparisons, click here). For families that can’t spend that much at once, or for people like me who shudder at the thought of spending that much money on anything, there are a number of strategies and resources to reduce the cost of cloth diapering even further. My goal is to help other families find the most cost-effective way to diaper their kids.

Strategies for Savings

Versatility: One of the best questions to ask yourself when trying to diaper on a budget is, “What diapers will give me the most use for my money?”  Depending on your individual needs, the best bet for you might be prefolds, which can be reused as rags once their diapering life is over, or one-size pocket diapers if you have multiple kids in diapers at the same time.

Sized vs. one-size: When buying cloth diapers on a budget, an obvious strategy is buying one-size diapers or covers that can be adjusted to fit infants through toddlers. With one-size diapers, there is no need for new diapers or covers as baby grows – just adjust the snaps!  One-size diapers are also a great option for families with multiple children in diapers, making it easier to find a diaper that fits. However, sized diapers tend to provide a better fit for very small newborns and larger toddlers who are still in diapers.

Is it a good price? When you think you find a great deal, particularly on-line, do a quick search and compare prices to other retailers. This is especially important when purchasing used diapers.  Is the price of the used diaper enough to justify the wear and tear?  I’m pretty stingy when it comes to purchasing used diapers, and I usually require a pretty sizable markdown.  Always remember to figure in shipping costs!  A great deal isn’t so great if shipping costs make it more expensive than purchasing from a local retailer.

How many diapers will we need? One easy way to blow a diaper budget is to buy more diapers than you actually need. We figure a diaper change about every two hours. If you have access to a washer and dryer to wash diapers every other day or so, you will need about twenty-four diapers and five to ten covers.

Affordable Options

Prefolds or flats and covers: Hands down, the most affordable option is using prefolds (rectangular flat cloth diaper with an absorbent center pad sewn in) or flats (large, square diapers made of a single layer of birdseye cotton that can be folded in a variety of ways to fit babies of different sizes) and waterproof covers. 

Seconds and discontinued items: Many manufacturers and retailers sell “seconds” (slightly imperfect but fully functional items) and discontinued products at deep discounts. Cloth Diaper Clearance is an example of a retailer that specializes in these products.

Cloth diaper registries: Creating baby registries on-line is a common way to let family and friends know what your need. Diaper retailers now offer this option too! We created a registry with diapers, covers, wipes, a wet bag, and a diaper pail that family and friends could access and order from online. When asked about your baby registry, share the link and let folks know that this gift would mean a lot!

Finding Used Diapers

Craigslist: CraigsList.org is local, allowing you to save on shipping, and giving you the opportunity to inspect the diapers before purchasing them.  The easiest way to find cloth diapers is to go to the “Baby and Kids” section of “For Sale” and do a search on “diapers.”  You’ll get a lot of other stuff, but this is the best way to catch all listings for cloth diapers.

DiaperSwappers.com: Since my son outgrew his first batch of covers, all of his covers have come from DiaperSwappers.com.  DiaperSwappers.com is a community forum organized by types of diapers and accessories that you must join (for free) in order to purchase diapers directly from the seller. In addition to being able to snag great deals, DiaperSwappers.com is a great place to find unique items at a great price.

Re-diaper.com: Unlike the person-to-person sales and trades, Re-diaper.com serves as a middleman, buying used diapers from families and reselling them.  Re-diaper only buys and sells name brands, like BumGenius and FuzziBunz. Some of the benefits of using Re-diaper.com include ease of use, consistent ratings of the condition of the diapers, and being able to combine multiple items in one shipping order. However, you can’t haggle or trade on Re-diaper.com, like you would be able to do on Craigslist or DiaperSwappers.com.

Local retailers: Check out any local retailers that carry cloth diaper supplies – they may offer used diapers at a deep discount.

Local consignment: Be sure to check out local baby and kids consignment sales, rummage sales, and thrift stores – they occasionally have cloth diapering supplies.

How “used” is it?: When considering used diapers for purchase, this is an important question to think about. How much life is left in the diaper? Do you have the skills to repair any rips or weaknesses? If you have to replace elastic, snaps, or Velcro, do the cost of those components outweigh the savings of purchasing a diaper? There are no hard and fast rules for this, and you’ll need to use your best judgment with each purchase.

Making Your Own

Resources abound online for making your own diapers, including many free patterns and instructions for creating diapers and covers from recycled clothing, like t-shirts and wool sweaters. The Mothering.com forums have a forum dedicated to resources and patterns for making your own diapers.

Cloth Diaper Assistance

If your budget doesn’t allow for the upfront cost of purchasing cloth diapers there are resources for free cloth diapers for families who demonstrate need. Re-diaper.com’s Cloth Diaper Loan Program and Giving Diapers Giving Hope provide free diapers, or diapers for the cost of shipping. Visit their websites for information on applying.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

Johanna Hatch, CD, CCE

Johanna is a doula, childbirth educator, writer, and feminist activist. Her writing has appeared in Spirit, US Catholic, From the Pews in the Back: Young Women and Catholicism, and the forthcoming anthologies Hungering and Thirsting for Justice and It's All in Her Head. Online, Johanna can be found tweeting occasionally @johanna_momma and blogging even more infrequently at The Little Stranger. She lives in Verona, WI with her spouse, son, and blind dachshund.

Website - Twitter - More Posts





Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
smokiechick 5 pts

So what are the best options for moms that need to go to the laundromat? I moved to an area with a diaper service - worth it for a mom that has to lug laundry and quarters across town (and hates every minute of it)?

AmyKnoch 8 pts

smokiechick Could be. Would probably be best to call around to the diaper services in your area and see what they're charging. If you're going to do it on your own, I'd say your best bet would probably be prefolds with covers, since the covers can be wiped or rinsed out in the sink easily and reused and then you could just get enough prefolds to last you a week, and then you're only doing 1 load of diaper laundry a week.

TheFeministBreeder 75 pts moderator

smokiechick We lived for a year in an apartment with no laundry. It was in the building, but FAR away. We handled it by having more diapers. If I didn't love my FuzziBunz so much, we would have just done a diaper service.

DoNotFaint 15 pts

TheFeministBreedersmokiechick The only diaper service in our area costs as much as 100% organic, biodegradable disposables; I did the math. We'd have to buy our own covers and they charge extra for wipes. It's totally crazy.

smokiechick 5 pts

DoNotFaintTheFeministBreedersmokiechick This is the local diaper service: http://www.smartypantsvt.com/

In the supermarket yesterday, a box of Pampers was about $30/box. Is what the diaper service offers a good deal? My other kid is 7 and I seem to have blocked all diaper related info, but I seem to remember moving in mostly Huggies boxes. I just don't remember how fast we went through the boxes.

smokiechick 5 pts

DoNotFaintTheFeministBreeder Oy, The link goes to the home page... It's a $49 set-up fee and $25/week for 80 small diapers, 60 medium, or 50 large. The set-up fee includes an orientation, among other things.

DoNotFaint 15 pts

smokiechickTheFeministBreeder That is the cutest diaper service *ever* but I'm in New Haven, CT. I don't think they'd drive down here for me! This is the one that covers New Haven: http://www.idiaperservice.com/Getting_Started.html and it's $28/week. There's no setup fee, but the first four weeks are, oddly enough, $28.50/week.

Definitely cheaper than the supermarket, yes, but I can buy Earth's Best diapers on Amazon, 160 smallest-88 biggest sizes, for $42. Free shipping. If the newborn goes through 10 diapers a day, that's still cheaper than the diaper service. That is 47% off the retail price, but it's been that price for a long time.

Please, correct my math if I am not taking some other cost into account! I would love for cloth diapers to make more sense for us, and we're still TTC so change our minds if you can! If Amazon raises prices to above $20/week, I'd be on the phone with iDiaper that minute. But $8/week plus the cost of buying covers? I can't justify it. Oh, how I long for laundry in the apartment!

AmyKnoch 8 pts

So, the cloth diaper foundation website appears to be defunct... and when I tried googling for it, I found this:

http://www.facebook.com/pages/The-New-Cloth-Diaper-Foundation/227280050622282?sk=wall

Apparently they are now closed (and apparently there was some kind of drama over people at the "old" cloth diaper foundation stealing diapers?)

wolfwoman 5 pts

AmyKnoch It was massive drama. And it didn't look like anyone was stealing anything from where I sat, watching the drama unfold. Basically, the CDF had some volunteers who helped with the gathering and sorting and shipping of diapers. These were typically moms with babies, and some or all of them were recipients of CDF diapers. There was a period when CDF was low on diapers and some people had to be turned away, but when that issue was resolved they made a rule that people had to wait to get the diapers until a month or two before their due dates. One of the volunteer moms made the mistake of setting some cute diapers aside for her own baby too far ahead of her due date, and then posted a picture of them on FB. It all looked pretty innocent to me, and the mom apologized profusely, saying she didn't realize she was breaking rules. A lot of people immediately had kittens in the way people do on the internet. They accused her of stealing, intentionally breaking the rules, flaunting her "secret stash", and refused to consider there was anything at all innocent happening. Other haters chimed in about the time (months earlier) when there weren't any diapers, and then even MORE people got their knickers in a bunch b/c clearly people in need were going without diapers b/c everyone working with CDF was taking ALL the donated diapers and keeping them, selling them, etc. The thing is, at the time of the fiasco they had so many diapers that they removed the requirement that people return the diapers. They were GIVING the diapers away for roughly $15 in service/shipping fees. It was insane, and it seemed to result in some people reporting the charity and all the people involved walking away. No idea whether they walked to try and save the charity, or because they couldn't take the insanity of the haters. It's really sad too b/c it was a great charity. I got three different sets of diapers for my daughters through them while I was trying to build my stash.

LeighPF 6 pts

We love our cloth diapers and for us fitteds and wool covers are working best.

If you would like to start using cloth, but the start up costs are beyond your budget, check out givingdiapersgivinghope.com. They lend diaper stashes out to low income families (anyone who qualifies for WIC).

TheFeministBreeder 75 pts moderator

LeighPF Thanks for the link!

hganshorn 6 pts

Some diaper shops also do trials - my local shop charge $250 for a 3-week trial of some of each of the diapers they sell. At the end of that time, they refunded me $200, plus charging me for the diapers I wanted to keep. It was great because my son was Mr. Blowout, and most of the dipes couldn't contain him, so I was able to find the brand that worked rather than investing in ones that were a poor fit (if you're curious about the most blowout-proof diapers, they were the MotherEase Sandy's with Bummis Superbrites covers).

Also, I really decided in the end that one-size aren't a great option. They are a poor fit for newborns (see blowouts, above), and they wear out with so much use. I have the BumGenius and they already have little holes in the cotton liner near the leg holes, plus the velcro is starting to lose its grip, so I'm not sure they'll last for baby #2.

TheFeministBreeder 75 pts moderator

hganshorn I've used FuzziBunz OneSize for my babies, and I love them because they fit great, and have snaps as opposed to velcro, which does wear out very quickly. I was able to adjust my FuzziBunz to go from my 40 lb toddler to my 10 lb newborn, and they're holding up great! I've never had a blow out with any kind of cloth diaper, and definitely not with my FuzziBunz One Size.

hganshorn 6 pts

TheFeministBreeder Yeah, at the time I couldn't find FB locally, and wanted to support my local diaper shop. And people raved about the BumGenius, but I'm not impressed, even though I have two with snaps. They fit fine from about six months old, but they haven't held up.